James M. & Sharon E. Rupp Debate Society at Idaho State University.
Wednesday, August 27, 2014
Welcome Back ISU Debate!
We are excited to start the 2014-2015 academic year today. Our first debate squad meeting is located in 410 Frazier Hall. The meeting runs from 3:00-5:00 pm. Feel free to drop by and find out about the opportunities available on the Idaho State Debate Team.
Thursday, May 22, 2014
Throwback Thursday
| Paul Montreuil & Scott Odekirk |
| Rachel Nicholas & Nate Murphy |
| Megan Demasters & Hannah Dunlop |
| Paul Montreuil, Lindsay Vanluvanee, Rachel Nicholas, Hannah Dunlop, Andy Ridgeway |
| Aaron Dekeyzer |
| Nichalle (Klosterboer) Dekeyzer |
| Sheldon Kreger |
| Skip Flinn & Lindsay Vanluvanee |
| Megan Demasters & Stefan Menses |
Thursday, May 15, 2014
Throw Back Thursday
Monday, May 5, 2014
Debating to Build Mental Strength: Part Three
by Dr. Sarah T. Partlow Lefevre
In part one and part two of this series, I introduced an article written by Paul Hudson called 20 Things Mentally Strong People Don’t Do. Upon initially reading the article, I noticed that many of the characteristics of mental strength could be developed through the practice of debate. Debate is an activity that promotes dialectic and argumentative interaction while accepting disagreement. The structure of debate lends itself to developing mental strength and healthy life perspective. In part three, I examine Hudsons’s suggestions 11-15 rephrasing them as affirmative practices in the context of competitive debate. Hudson’s things that mentally strong people don’t do are:
11. Trying To Please People
12. Debaters recognize that there are some things they cannot control.
13. Debaters learn that persistence and hard work produce dividends.
14. Debaters recognize that they are responsible for crafting and refining the messages that they communicate.
15. Debaters know they must earn their success.
In part one and part two of this series, I introduced an article written by Paul Hudson called 20 Things Mentally Strong People Don’t Do. Upon initially reading the article, I noticed that many of the characteristics of mental strength could be developed through the practice of debate. Debate is an activity that promotes dialectic and argumentative interaction while accepting disagreement. The structure of debate lends itself to developing mental strength and healthy life perspective. In part three, I examine Hudsons’s suggestions 11-15 rephrasing them as affirmative practices in the context of competitive debate. Hudson’s things that mentally strong people don’t do are:
11. Trying To Please People
12. Blaming
Themselves For Things Outside Their Control
13. Being
Impatient
14. Being
Misunderstood
15. Feeling Like
You’re Owed
Because debate is a training ground, I rephrase each as an aspect of debate
that can develop mental strength.
11. Debaters recognize when they’ve done
their best regardless of the results.
While the structure of debate asks debaters to please the
judge, mentally strong debaters also must do their best and accept that there
are some results that rest outside of their control. Because the judge is a human being and--by
nature--imperfect, the very best performance might not yield a victory. Mentally strong debaters recognize that the
decision making process is also about the judge – their thoughts and
predispositions, their moods, or even their human foibles. A mentally strong debater understands that
strategy in debate is about more than a virtuoso performance – it is also about
adapting to the judge. Additionally, a
strong debater recognizes that doing one’s best doesn’t always mean marking a
win on the results sheet. Even in these
cases, a strong debater is proud of doing his or her best.
12. Debaters recognize that there are some things they cannot control.
Debate is a game of control.
If debaters can control the variables, they are more likely to win. However, even in such an intricate and
strategic game, there are elements of chance.
Mentally strong debaters know this.
They recognize that they might draw tough opponents, fail to find the
best evidence, run out of time in their speeches, make a mistake, or end up
disagreeing with a judge. Debaters learn
that this is inevitable in debate and in life.
Debaters learn from experience that their control is not absolute. This means they must do their best and
recognize that some factors are not within the realm of their control. Letting go of the notion that total control
of the situation is possible frees debaters to be their best. Win or lose, they must learn not to blame
themselves and by extension not to blame the judge –a fellow human being.
13. Debaters learn that persistence and hard work produce dividends.
Many people who start debating do not ever succeed because
they are not persistent. If individuals
begin debate and do not persist, they may not experience the benefits of
debate. Like many things that are worth
doing, debate requires hard work over a sustained period of time. But, the rewards that come from sticking with
it go far beyond trophies. Debaters
experience personal growth and transformation.
They develop life skills and analytic skills in a dynamic
environment. Sometimes the process
hurts. Mentally strong debaters learn to
embrace the adversity as a method of intellectual and personal growth. Debaters who stick with it develop amazing
analytic skills and begin to win. But,
often winning takes time.
14. Debaters recognize that they are responsible for crafting and refining the messages that they communicate.
Mentally strong debaters understand
that they are responsible for what they communicate to the judge. Debate is a process of persuading the judge
as a specific audience in a dialectical environment. In that sense, the judge has a particular set
of life experiences, debate experience, academic knowledge, debate knowledge,
and different preferences that may all influence his or her response to the
round. Strong debaters seek to
understand the perspectives of the judge rather than to blame the judge for
voting against them. For those who are
not mentally strong, every debate victory is about their skill as debaters
while every loss is about the stupidity of the judge. Mentally strong debaters recognize the
possibility that they might be wrong in any given debate. Recognizing their potential weaknesses allows
debaters to identify flaws in their communication and to remedy them. Fundamentally, it is a debater’s
responsibility to communicate clearly and persuasively.
15. Debaters know they must earn their success.
Mentally strong debaters recognize that debate doesn’t owe them
anything but offers many things.
Participation in debate builds research skills, the ability to
understand and process complex material, strategic thinking, speaking skills,
and many other benefits. Mentally strong
debaters understand that each of these benefits is multiplied through hard work
and practice. Expecting to have success
handed to you leads to disappointment in debate and in life. Often, debaters develop mental strength as
they learn to thrive on the challenge and to hone their debate skills. Accepting that rewards are earned serves
debaters well throughout their lives.
I hope you are enjoying the series. Feel free to comment or make suggestions.
Part four is coming soon.
Thursday, May 1, 2014
Throwback Thursday
Wednesday, April 30, 2014
End of Year Squad Dinner, April 30, 2014
| Roger Copenhaver |
| Krystal Lynes & SamRichardson |
| Anne Johnson & Zach Sayles |
| Sam Richardson, Logan, and Robyn Hemmert |
| Kendra Doty & Sarah Partlow Lefevre
Thanks for a great year!
See squad award winners here.
|
![]() |
| Examples of the word cloud recognition for the debaters. |
ISU Squad Award Winners: 2013-2014
| Kendra Doty, ISU Debater of the Year. |
| Matea Ivanovic, ISU Debater of the Year. |
| Samantha Richardson, ISU Squad Spirit Award. |
| Roger Copenhaver, ISU Squad Service Award. |
| Mike Eyre & Sasha Ivanovic, Most Improved Debate Team. |
| Robyn Hemmert & Anne Johnson, ISU Novice Debate Tea of the Year. |
| Brock Sondrup & Jakob Meng, ISU Junior Varsity Debate Team of the Year. |
| Kendra Doty & Matea Ivanovic, ISU Senior Debate Team of the Year. Congratulations to all our debaters! See pictures from the dinner here. |
Tuesday, April 29, 2014
Debating to Build Mental Strength: Part Two
by Dr. Sarah T. Partlow Lefevre
Part three can be found here. I hope you are enjoying the series so far. Comments and suggestions are welcome.
In part
one of this series, I introduced an article written by Paul Hudson called 20 Things Mentally Strong People Don’t Do.
I applied his first five suggestions to the debate context. In part two, I examine practices 6-10 that
mentally strong people should avoid.
They are:
6.
Letting Others Make Decisions For Them
7.
Getting Jealous Over The Successes Of Others
8.
Thinking About The High Possibility Of Failure
9.
Feeling Sorry For Themselves
10.
Focusing On Their Weaknesses (Hudson,
2014)
Again, I apply each suggestion
in the context of debate to see how debaters can use the activity to build
mental strength and resilience.
Debaters who develop such habits can use them to become more successful
throughout their lives.
6. Debaters develop decision making abilities.
Debaters learn to consider the advice of others, while relying on their decision making abilities in every debate. Often, a coach may discuss a strategy with a debater prior to a debate. However, debaters must develop the ability to implement such strategies in context, to choose between a variety of strategies, and to develop strategies on their own. As debaters learn to engage in high level strategic thinking, they are more and more able to make the decisions they are called upon to make in the heat of the moment. Wise debaters listen to their coaches. But, they also listen to themselves.
Debaters learn to consider the advice of others, while relying on their decision making abilities in every debate. Often, a coach may discuss a strategy with a debater prior to a debate. However, debaters must develop the ability to implement such strategies in context, to choose between a variety of strategies, and to develop strategies on their own. As debaters learn to engage in high level strategic thinking, they are more and more able to make the decisions they are called upon to make in the heat of the moment. Wise debaters listen to their coaches. But, they also listen to themselves.
Debaters also learn to research options and investigate possibilities
by considering a wide variety of evidence from many sources. Not only are debaters taught to analyze the quality
of the available evidence, they learn to synthesize it into a coherent
perspective. Debaters learn the tools
for decision making in a variety of contexts.
They can consistently and fairly engage in cost benefit analysis to
weigh competing merits of different approaches.
In the long run, good debaters develop the ability to address a problem
by gathering evidence, analyzing it, and deciding for themselves.
7. Debaters celebrate others’ successes.
It takes a debater who is truly confident in him or herself to
celebrate others’ successes. Strong
debaters should revel in the process of debate and reach out to others –win or
lose. As one who has been around the
debate community for many years, I know that team success works in cycles. But, it is always true that when one team
wins accolades and respect, debate as an activity wins. Mentally strong debaters should remember to
be proud of the other members of the debate community and to celebrate their
successes. Trophies are only a small
part of the debate experience. More than
any individual win or loss, debate is nothing without individuals contributing
to and building the community. Resilient
debaters reach out to others and build bridges without regard to competitive
concerns. Often, debaters develop
extensive networks of friends all over the country. Such deep bonds last well beyond a single
tournament, a specific season, or even a debate career. These bonds last a lifetime.
8. Debaters accept guaranteed failure.
Because debate tournaments involve a series of debates and, therefore,
a series of wins and losses, even tournament champions rarely emerge
undefeated. In debate, losing is
inevitable. All debaters lose
debates. Losses can help debaters to
refine strategy and improve their arguments.
A loss can identify weaknesses in an argument that need to be
addressed. Losses can inspire debaters to
do more research, practice more, or to try harder in the next debate. Ultimately, losing in debate teaches mentally
strong debaters that loss is a part of life.
Using the experience of failure to refine one’s approach and to try
again another day marks debaters’ progress.
Resilient debaters learn how to take failure in stride while still
progressing in life and in debate. In
this way, failure in debate leads to success in life as individuals learn to
accept the inevitability of defeat and to respond constructively.
9. Debaters do not pity
themselves. Instead, they make
themselves better.
After accepting that loss is inevitable, debaters
are free to use losing as an exercise in self-improvement. Mentally strong
debaters learn from their losses rather than engaging in self-pity. Debaters should embrace the experience of
debate and dialogue while seeking to improve their skills. Enjoying the process ensures an attitude that
allows for personal growth and development.
10. Debaters capitalize on their strengths.
To succeed, debaters must recognize and use their strengths as
speakers, strategists, or researchers.
Tough debaters recognize that nurturing strength will make them stronger
and more successful. Most debaters also
work on improving in weak areas. But,
the ability to identify areas of excellence and refine them is what makes a
great debater.
Part three can be found here. I hope you are enjoying the series so far. Comments and suggestions are welcome.
Monday, April 28, 2014
Debating to Build Mental Strength: Part One
by Dr. Sarah T. Partlow Lefevre
This morning I read an Elite Daily article by Paul Hudson called 20 Things Mentally Strong People Don’t Do. The first five mental habits to avoid include:
This morning I read an Elite Daily article by Paul Hudson called 20 Things Mentally Strong People Don’t Do. The first five mental habits to avoid include:
1. Dwelling On
The Past
2. Remaining In
Their Comfort Zone
3. Not Listening
To The Opinions Of Others
4. Avoiding
Change
5. Keeping A
Closed Mind (Hudson,
2014)
While most of these suggestions are good advice, they resonate in the context of debate.
Debate as an activity trains people to be mentally strong. Based on Hudson’s suggestions, I propose a
list of practices in debate that make individuals mentally strong. Debaters who adopt these approaches will
succeed in debate and will develop habits that promote success in other areas
of their lives.
1. Debaters look to the future.
Debaters develop the ability to move on after experiencing loss. Half of all teams loose in every debate. Mentally strong debaters learn to set their
losses aside and focus on preparing for the next debate. They transition quickly from debate to debate
and learn to compartmentalize their experiences in a productive way. Dwelling on past losses is a recipe for
failure in debate. Winning debaters
learn to live in the moment and learn from their experiences without dwelling
on setbacks.
2. Debaters regularly overcome fear and step outside of their comfort zones.
By nature, debate takes individuals out their comfort zones because
speaking in front of others is scary. In
fact, it is the “No. 1 fear reported by people in the U.S.” (WebMD). Fear is a natural human response to speaking in
public. Most public speakers experience some level of fear or anxiety. Debaters experience this too. Debaters often leave their comfort zones and
gain strength in the process.
Ultimately, doing something that you fear is an incredibly empowering
experience. After debaters know they can
debate, they also know they can start a business, apply for graduate school,
give a speech at a wedding, go to law school, get a Ph.D. or a
Master’s degree, and do many other challenging things. Debaters learn to
overcome fear while gaining confidence and to seek difficult experiences that
reap splendid rewards.
3. Debaters listen to and learn from everyone they can.
First, successful debaters engage opponents.
Some debaters are so prepared that they fail to listen to their
opponents’ arguments. Without listening,
debaters cannot possibly hope to understand and adequately respond to the claims
advanced in the debate. Successful
debaters do not underestimate their opponents or assume that they understand
their arguments in advance. Rather,
successful debaters develop the habit of listening to their opponents and responding
to the strongest possible incarnation of their arguments. Listening to the opposition and understanding
other perspectives is a key component of building mental strength in debate.
Second, debaters often have the opportunity to interact with the other
coaches, the judges, and the other teams.
Debaters should take these opportunities to learn everything they can
from others in the debate community.
Such knowledge ranges from how to better answer an argument to where to
access particular academic research to how to improve their persuasive
skills. Win or lose, debaters who listen
become better because they are open to others’ ideas and approaches to the
world.
4. Debaters embrace change on many levels.
Debaters face a torrent of change. Topics, argumentative norms, styles
of delivery, persuasive tactics, opponents, judges, locations, and many more
things constantly change in debate. The ability to
accept, adapt to, and learn from these changes makes debaters flexible,
adaptable individuals who will become strong team players in any environment. The ability to embrace and quickly adapt to
change gives debaters a competitive advantage as others strive to catch
up.
5. Debaters keep open minds.
In debate, students are usually asked to represent multiple approaches to
the same or similar topics. Asking students
to represent multiple sides of an issue is often referred to as switch side
debate. As students switch sides, they develop
intricate understandings of many perspectives.
While debaters may maintain the courage of their convictions, openness to
understanding and engaging a variety of arguments builds mental strength and
the capacity to build higher quality, more nuanced arguments.
This is part one of a four part series.
In the next three installments, I will address the remaining components
of Hudson’s list. Please comment and let
me know what you liked or didn’t like about this post. See part two here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




